Zalmoxis

When thunder came down over the lower Danube, the Getae walked out of their houses and shot arrows into it. Not at an enemy in the cloud. At the god. Herodotus, who collected the story around 430 BCE, understood the gesture as a threat rather than a prayer, and he adds that these people recognised no god but their own.

He calls them the bravest and most law-abiding of the Thracians, and then gets to the thing that actually interested him: they believed they did not die. Not that they were spared it. Whoever perished simply went to Zalmoxis, whom some of them called Gebeleizis instead, and that was the whole of the matter. Death was a change of address.

Every four years they checked that the arrangement still held. A man was chosen by lot and told exactly what the people wanted that year. Three others planted their spears and held them steady while the rest took the messenger by the hands and the feet, swung him, and threw him out over the points. If the iron went through him, the god was taken to be willing. If he survived, the fault was his and nobody else’s: they told him to his face that he was a bad man, and picked someone better. The message was always given before the throw. There would be no time for it afterwards.

That is the Getic account, as far as a Greek traveller could reconstruct it. The Greeks living along the Hellespont and the Black Sea coast told him something else, and they told it with a smirk. In their version Zalmoxis was no god at all but a slave, bought on Samos by Pythagoras, freed with money, and sent home to a country they considered poor and its people slow. He built himself a hall in the Thracian manner and began feeding the leading men of the district, pouring wine and explaining to them over the meat that neither he nor they nor any of their descendants would ever die, but would go on to a place where every good thing waited. All the while a chamber was being cut underneath the floor.

When it was finished he stepped down into it and vanished. The Getae mourned him as dead. He stayed under the ground for three years, in the cold and the dark and whatever a man does with that much time, and in the fourth year he came back up, and the doctrine was no longer a claim.

Herodotus refuses to settle it. He neither disbelieves the story nor accepts it, notes that by his own reckoning Zalmoxis lived many years before Pythagoras was born, and then puts the question aside entirely: whether there was ever such a man, or whether this is simply a god native to the Getae, let it go. It is one of the more honest sentences in ancient ethnography.

Nobody ever says what he looked like. No statue is described, no face, no attribute carried in the hand, nothing that a coin or a relief could be matched against. What survives instead is a room, and after that a mountain. Four centuries later Strabo tells a fuller version of the same shape. Zamolxis learned the movement of the heavens from Pythagoras and more of it from wandering among the Egyptians, came home able to predict from celestial signs, and made himself useful enough that the king took him as a partner in government. First he was priest of the god the Getae honoured most. Then he was called a god himself. He withdrew into a cavern on a mountain named Kogaionon, with a river of the same name running below it, saw almost nobody, and passed word out through the king. The office outlasted him. Decaeneus held it under Burebista in the first century BCE and persuaded the Getae to dig up their vines and live without wine. A priesthood whose best-recorded triumph is national abstinence has a certain flavour to it.

The healing tradition is older than Strabo and better attested than any of it. In Plato’s Charmides, Socrates claims to have picked up a charm on campaign in Thrace from one of the physicians of Zalmoxis, who are said even to make men immortal. The charm is not a herb. It is speech. You cannot treat the eyes apart from the head, the Thracian told him, nor the head apart from the body, nor the body apart from the soul, and the soul is treated with beautiful words, and the words produce temperance, and the temperance produces health. The oldest surviving Greek statement of psychosomatic medicine is put into the mouth of a foreigner from north of the Danube.

The name itself resists everyone. Porphyry, writing in the third century CE, derived it from zalmos, a hide, and told a story about a bear’s skin thrown over the infant at birth. Diogenes Laertius repeats the bear skin. Hesychius separately records zemelen as a Phrygian word for a foreign slave, which fits the Samos story a little too neatly to be trusted. None of it is secure.

His powers are few, and they follow from the one thing he was for. He receives the dead and keeps them, alive and provided for, in a place the sources never describe. He answers questions, once every four years, delivered by spear. Through his priests he reads the sky and heals with words. He throws no lightning, sends no flood, takes no animal shape, fathers no heroes.

The limits are stranger than the powers. There is no myth of Zalmoxis. No parents, no consort, no rival, no battle, no death, not even a proper birth beyond the bear skin. Every word we have about him was written by people who did not worship him, in a language he was not worshipped in, and mostly with an eyebrow raised. The Getae left nothing written that survives. The arrows make their own point: whatever else he was, he was a god a man could shoot at. The cult does not appear to have outlived the Roman conquest of Dacia in 106 CE.

Most of what circulates today as Zalmoxian religion is younger than the twentieth century. Mircea Eliade’s Zalmoxis: The Vanishing God, published in 1972, turned the three years underground into an initiation and the god into one who withdraws and returns, and that reading was taken up with enthusiasm by Romanian nationalist writing about a spiritual Dacian past. Dan Dana’s 2008 study followed the whole growth of it, from Herodotus to Eliade, and found more pretext than god. The monotheism, the mystery cult, the doctrine of resurrection: largely a modern inheritance. The ancient record is thinner and a good deal odder. A hall, a hole cut under the floor, three years, and a man coming back up the steps.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is Zalmoxis?

Zalmoxis is the god of the Getae, a Thracian people who lived north of the lower Danube in what is now Romania and Bulgaria. Herodotus, writing around 430 BCE, reports that the Getae believed their dead did not perish but went to him. Some of them called him Gebeleizis instead, and they recognised no other god.

Was Zalmoxis a god or a man?

Herodotus deliberately refuses to answer. He records a Greek story that Zalmoxis was a former slave of Pythagoras who faked his own death and reappeared after three years in an underground chamber, but says he neither disbelieves nor believes it, and adds that Zalmoxis lived many years before Pythagoras. Strabo later describes him as a man who became a priest and then was called a god.

How did the Getae send messages to Zalmoxis?

Every four years the Getae chose a man by lot, told him what to ask the god for, and threw him onto three upheld spears. If the spears killed him, they took it as a sign that the god was favourable. If he survived, they declared the messenger a bad man and sent someone else.

What does the name Zalmoxis mean?

No one is certain. Porphyry derived it from a Thracian word zalmos, meaning hide or skin, and told a story about a bear skin thrown over Zalmoxis at birth; Diogenes Laertius repeats the bear skin. Hesychius separately records a Phrygian word zemelen meaning foreign slave, which matches the Greek slave story a little too conveniently.

Is the modern Zalmoxis cult ancient?

Largely not. The picture of Zalmoxis at the centre of a Dacian mystery religion with initiation and resurrection owes a great deal to Mircea Eliade’s 1972 book Zalmoxis: The Vanishing God and to later Romanian nationalist writing. Dan Dana’s 2008 study traced how that reading developed. The ancient sources are far thinner and much less systematic.

Related Entries

Gebeleizis, Solomonari, Iele, Balaur, Zmeu, Sabazios, Cabeiri, Orpheus, Dionysus, Hades, Persephone, Osiris, Asclepius