Pandi

Pandi

Also Known As: Greek Πανδαι, Pandai; Latin Pandae; also given as Pandarae and Pandian; distinct from the northern Panotii
Region/Culture: South Asia
Mythos: Greek Mythology, Roman Mythology, Medieval Mythology
Primary Type/Nature: Monsters and Beasts
Mythical Attributes: They age in reverse colour, born white-haired and turning black by sixty, and reach two hundred years in a country where the neighbouring peoples are said not to pass forty.
Role in Mythos: They are one of the wonder-peoples of the Greek and Roman ethnography of India, a warlike mountain nation supplying five thousand bowmen and spearmen to the king of India.
Relation to Humans: They are not hostile to outsiders and are described as subjects and soldiers of an Indian king rather than as a menace to travellers. No encounter story survives in which anyone meets them; they exist entirely as a report brought back to the Persian court and written down by a Greek who never saw them.

The bamboo in those valleys grows so thick that two men together can barely get their arms around a single stem, and it stands as tall as the mast of a merchantman. The sun overhead looks ten times its proper size. Somewhere in the shade of that reed, five thousand archers are forming into column to march with the king of India, and every one of them is white-haired, and every one of them is young.

That is the whole trick of the Pandi, and it is a good one. Their hair does not go white with age. It starts white. Children are born with white hair on the head and on the eyebrows, and the men carry white hair over the entire body until they are about thirty. Then it begins to darken. By sixty it is completely black. Their old men are the black-haired ones.

The rest of the description is stranger still and given with the same flat confidence. They have eight fingers on each hand and eight toes on each foot, men and women alike. Their children arrive with a full set of teeth already in the upper and lower jaw. And the ears, which are the thing everyone remembers: long enough to lie down over the arms as far as the elbow and to cover the back at the same time, so that the two of them meet behind. About thirty thousand of them live in the mountains where the Indian reed grows. The women bear a child once in their lives and never again.

Picture a Pandi woman at a spring in the reed country, the water cold off the rock, holding up the only child she will ever have, and the infant smiling back at her with a complete set of teeth under a shock of white hair and white brows. Nobody in that scene finds any of it remarkable. It is simply what people look like.

The report comes from a single man, and it is worth naming him, because everything written about the Pandi for the next two thousand years runs back through him. Ctesias of Cnidus was a Greek physician who spent seventeen years at the court of Artaxerxes II of Persia, from about 404 BCE, and he never crossed into India in his life. What he had was the Persian court: envoys, merchants, soldiers, gossip carried up the road from the Indus. Out of that he wrote the Indica, and the Indica is lost. What survives is a summary made in the ninth century by the Byzantine scholar Photius, plus quotations in Pliny the Elder and Aelian. Photius describes the long-eared people in his summary and never gives them a name. The name Pandae comes from Pliny, who credits Ctesias for the two-hundred-year lifespan and the hair that goes from white to black, and who places them in the mountain valleys next to another long-lived people the Greeks called the Macrobians.

There is a decent chance the whole nation is a mistranslation. Rudolf Wittkower, working on where these eastern marvels came from, pointed to a Sanskrit word that appears in the Mahabharata as the name of a people: karnapravarana, those who cover themselves with their ears. It is the sort of phrase a Greek visitor would hear from a Brahman informant, take down word for word, and hand on to a reader with no way of telling a metaphor from a measurement. A cloak becomes anatomy. Once written, it stayed written.

The name has its own tangle. A generation after Ctesias, Megasthenes went to India as an ambassador to Chandragupta Maurya, and he brought back a Pandaia who was no monster at all. She was the only daughter Heracles fathered in India, and because she was his only daughter he gave her a kingdom in the south and made it hers, five hundred elephants, four thousand horse and a hundred and thirty thousand foot, and from her the country took its name and became the one nation in India ruled by women. Scholars have long since lined Pandaia up with the Pandya kingdom of the Tamil south, which was entirely real and left inscriptions. So the same syllables carry a genuine dynasty and a fabulous eight-fingered mountain tribe, and no ancient writer ever troubles to sort them out.

The medieval world had no interest in sorting them out either. It inherited the whole catalogue of Plinian races through Isidore and the bestiaries, painted them around the rims of the world maps, and cut them into woodblocks, so that men with ears for blankets were still walking through printed books in the 1490s. By then the Pandi had a neighbour and rival in the picture trade, the Panotii, a separate long-eared people whom Pliny put on frozen islands in the north. The two get confused constantly. The Pandi are the Indian ones, and they are the ones with the extra fingers.

What they can do follows from what they are. They outlast everyone. Two hundred years, against neighbours who Pliny says do not reach forty, and healthy the whole way, since Ctesias insists the Indians know nothing of headache or toothache or sores. They are warlike and they are good with a bow, good enough that five thousand of them go out with the king on campaign, and the ears and the extra fingers are given without a hint that either is a burden.

The limits are just as plain, and they are demographic rather than heroic. A nation of thirty thousand in which each woman bears once can never grow, only hold steady or shrink, and it hands five thousand fighting men to somebody else’s war. They have no god, no founding story, no enemy and no tale of their own. They cannot be killed by a hero because no hero was ever sent against them. The only real danger they ever faced was the loss of the book they lived in, and that has already happened.

What is left is a few sentences in a Byzantine abstract of a vanished Greek manuscript, and inside those sentences one detail nobody would bother to invent: that the ears are long enough that the two of them touch behind the back.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the Pandi?

The Pandi, also spelled Pandae, are a legendary people of Greek and Roman accounts of India, described as living in mountain valleys with enormous ears, eight fingers on each hand and eight toes on each foot. They were first described by the Greek physician Ctesias of Cnidus in the early fourth century BCE and later named and repeated by Pliny the Elder. They belong to the group of wonder-peoples that medieval Europe called the monstrous races.

Why do the Pandi have white hair when young and black hair when old?

According to Ctesias, Pandi children are born with white hair on the head and eyebrows, and the men are white-haired over the whole body until about the age of thirty. After thirty the hair begins to darken, and by sixty it is entirely black. Pliny the Elder repeats this and adds that the Pandi live for two hundred years.

How big are the ears of the Pandi?

Ctesias states that Pandi ears are long enough to cover their arms as far as the elbow and to cover their backs at the same time, so that one ear touches the other behind them. This is the detail that made them memorable in medieval bestiaries and world maps. It should not be confused with the Panotii, a separate long-eared people whom Pliny placed on islands in the far north rather than in India.

Were the Pandi real?

There is no evidence that any people matching the description existed. Rudolf Wittkower suggested the Pandi grew out of a Sanskrit name recorded in the Mahabharata, karnapravarana, meaning those who cover themselves with their ears, which a Greek listener may have taken literally as a description of anatomy. The name itself is also tangled with Pandaia, the kingdom Megasthenes said Heracles gave his daughter, which scholars identify with the historical Pandya kingdom of southern India.

Who wrote about the Pandi?

The original account is by Ctesias of Cnidus, a Greek doctor at the Persian court of Artaxerxes II who never visited India and worked from reports reaching Persia. His book, the Indica, is lost and survives only through a ninth-century summary by the Byzantine scholar Photius and through quotations in Pliny the Elder and Aelian. Pliny supplies the name Pandae and the two-hundred-year lifespan.

Related Entries

Panotti, Astomi, Blemmyae, Cynocephalus, Monopod, Nuli, Syrictæ, Abarimon, Arimaspi, Pygmy, Satyrus, Manticore, Unicorn, Griffin (or Gryphon), Gold-digging ant