
Necromancy is a Greek compound: nekros, a corpse or the dead, and manteia, divination. It means finding things out from the dead. It does not mean commanding them.
That matters, because the modern picture of the necromancer is almost entirely about command: the robed figure raising a skeleton army, the undead sorcerer who has hidden his soul in a jar. The best-known version of that figure, the lich, is an American invention of 1975. The older necromancers wanted something much smaller and much harder to get. They wanted an answer.
This article follows the practice through the places where the evidence is good: a cuneiform ritual for seeing ghosts, a pit dug on the shore of Ocean, a woman at Endor, a Roman poet’s nightmare, a medieval handbook in Munich, and a mountain in northern Japan where the dead still talk. It also separates three figures that are easily run together: the person who calls the dead up, the person who goes down to them, and the person who walks them to where they are going. The third, the escort, has its own two-part series on this site, beginning with Who Comes For You When You Die.
Mesopotamia: A Hole in the Earth
In Mesopotamia every person became a ghost at death: a gidim in Sumerian, eṭemmu in Akkadian. The ghost kept its memory and personality and went down to the land of the dead, where its comfort depended on the living continuing to feed it. A neglected ghost came back hungry, as the restless edimmu.
The clearest scene of consulting the dead is in the Epic of Gilgamesh. Its twelfth tablet is, as Andrew George notes, a close Akkadian translation of the last part of an older Sumerian poem. Enkidu goes down into the netherworld and is seized there. Gilgamesh appeals to the gods, and at the word of Ea (the Sumerian Enki), the warrior god Nergal opens a hole in the earth. Enkidu’s ghost comes up through it like a breath of wind, and Gilgamesh questions him about what he has seen.
The answers are a survey of the afterlife by social circumstance. The man with many sons sits among the junior gods and listens to the proceedings. The man with no heir to make offerings eats bread as hard as fired brick. The dead do not report on morality. They report on who remembered them.
That was literature. Actual practice survives too. Irving Finkel of the British Museum has published cuneiform instructions for necromancy, among them tablet K.2779, a Neo-Babylonian text of the seventh century BCE. It calls for an ointment of oils, beer, plants and animal fats, applied to the eyes so that the practitioner can see the ghost and speak with it. Another ritual calls on Shamash, the sun god who travels through the underworld each night. A specialist called the mušēlû eṭemmi, “one who brings up a ghost”, appears in the texts, though some Assyriologists read the same causative verb as “removes”, which would make him an exorcist instead.
What makes K.2779 unusual is that it summons at all. Most of the Mesopotamian material on ghosts, including the 352 prescriptions JoAnn Scurlock has edited, is about making them go away.
Odysseus at the Pit
The oldest full necromancy in Greek literature is Book 11 of the Odyssey, the episode later called the nekyia. It is not a journey to the underworld, and it is worth reading closely because the popular memory of it is wrong on exactly that point.
Circe gives Odysseus the procedure before he leaves Aeaea. He sails to the edge of the world, digs a pit about a cubit square, pours libations of milk and honey, wine and water, scatters barley, and cuts the throats of a ram and a black ewe over it. Then he sits beside the pit with his sword drawn. The dead come up to the blood. He holds them all back until the seer Tiresias has drunk, because it is Tiresias he has come to ask.
The blood is the mechanism. A Homeric shade has a face and a voice and no strength. Odysseus’s own mother, Anticleia, does not recognise him until she has drunk. Once she has, she speaks truthfully. The dead that follow include Achilles, who says he would rather be a hired labourer for a poor man on earth than king over all the dead.
Odysseus never goes down. The dead come up to him. That is the difference between necromancy and descent, and it is the same shape as Enkidu’s ghost rising through a hole.
The Greeks also had fixed places for this. Herodotus tells how Periander, tyrant of Corinth, sent to the oracle of the dead on the river Acheron in Thesprotia to ask his dead wife Melissa where a guest’s deposit had been hidden (Histories 5.92). Her ghost refused. She was cold and naked, she said, because the clothes buried with her had not been burned and were no use to her. As proof of identity she added a detail about Periander’s conduct with her corpse that only she could know. Periander summoned the women of Corinth to the temple of Hera, had them stripped by his guards, burned their clothes for Melissa, and asked again. This time she answered.
Daniel Ogden’s Greek and Roman Necromancy surveys the known oracles of the dead: the cave sites at Tainaron and Heraclea Pontica, and the lakeside precincts at the Acheron and at Avernus in Italy. The building visitors are shown today as the Acheron nekromanteion, excavated by Sotirios Dakaris from 1958, is disputed. In 1979 Dietwulf Baatz identified bronze fittings Dakaris had taken for parts of a crane as washers from catapults, and many archaeologists now read the site as a fortified Hellenistic farmhouse. Ogden argues the oracle has been misidentified.
The Woman at Endor
The most famous necromancer in the Western tradition has no name, and the title she is usually given is not in the text.
In 1 Samuel 28, the Philistines are gathering against Israel and Saul can get no answer from God, “neither by dreams, nor by Urim, nor by prophets”. He asks his servants to find him ʾēšet baʿălat-ʾôb: a woman who is mistress of an ʾôb. The meaning of ʾôb is uncertain. It can mean the spirit of a dead person, or the person who consults one, and in 1967 Harry Hoffner connected it to a Hittite word for a ritual pit. The Greek Septuagint translated her as an engastrimythos, a “belly-talker”. The English “witch” arrives much later: the 1611 King James Bible’s chapter summary says Saul “seeketh to a witch” and that “the witch… raiseth up Samuel”. The phrase “Witch of Endor” is English tradition, not the Hebrew.
Two details from the chapter are usually dropped. First, Saul himself had expelled the mediums from the land (28:3), so he comes to her disguised, at night, asking her to break his own law. Second, when she brings Samuel up, she sees ʾĕlōhîm, a divine being, “coming up out of the earth”: an old man wrapped in a robe. The direction is up again.
Samuel foretells Saul’s defeat and death the next day. Saul falls to the ground; he has not eaten all day. And then the woman, who has just been lied to and endangered by the king who outlawed her trade, insists he eat. She kills the fatted calf in her house and bakes unleavened bread, and feeds him and his men before they go out into the dark.
The Hebrew text does not condemn her, and nothing in it says she failed. The practice is forbidden elsewhere (Leviticus 19:31, Deuteronomy 18:11), and 1 Chronicles 10:13 lists the consultation among the reasons Saul died. The historian Josephus, writing in the first century CE, went further than the Bible in her favour: he praises her generosity at length and holds her up as an example, because she had one calf and gave it to the man who had ruined her. Jewish and Christian interpreters spent centuries on the harder question, which was whether Samuel really came. Origen said yes. Eustathius of Antioch wrote a whole treatise, On the Belly-Myther, arguing that it was a demonic illusion, because no demon could bring up the soul of a righteous man. Esther Hamori’s Women’s Divination in Biblical Literature places her alongside Israel’s female prophets and argues that the texts draw far less of a line between prophecy and other kinds of divination than their readers do.
Orpheus Went Down, Which Is Different
Orpheus is usually filed with the necromancers, and he does not belong there. He summons no one. He goes down to Hades and Persephone in person, which makes his story a katabasis, a descent, and his is far from the earliest. The Sumerian goddess Inanna descends to the realm of her sister Ereshkigal and is hung on a hook as a corpse, in a poem far older than any Greek text, and Enkidu’s descent is in the same Sumerian tradition.
The story of his wife is also less fixed than it looks. The earliest surviving mention of Orpheus by name is in the poet Ibycus, around 530 BCE. Euripides alludes to the descent in Alcestis in 438 BCE. Plato’s Symposium says the gods showed Orpheus only a phantom of his wife, because a musician would not die for love. Several early allusions, in Isocrates, the Hellenistic poet Hermesianax and the historian Diodorus, imply that he succeeded. Hermesianax calls her Agriope; the name Eurydice first appears in a Hellenistic lament for the poet Bion. The prohibition on looking back, and the second loss, first survive in Virgil’s Georgics (29 BCE), where the story is framed by Aristaeus and his dying bees. Ovid’s Metamorphoses made Virgil’s version the standard one.
Orpheus’s real connection to prophecy comes after his death. His severed head, in the tradition, floated singing to Lesbos, where an oracle of Orpheus was said to have stood at Antissa. Philostratus, in his Life of Apollonius, has Apollo come to the head in person and tell it to stop taking his business. And gold tablets buried with the dead in southern Italy and Greece, often called Orphic, instruct the dead soul to avoid the first spring it meets and drink from the lake of Mnemosyne, Memory. Here the living are not consulting the dead. They are sending them down with directions.
Odin Wakes a Seeress
The Norse sources have necromancy too, and the necromancer is a god. In the Eddic poem Baldrs draumar, Balder is having bad dreams, and Odin rides down toward Hel to find out why. At the eastern door he finds the grave of a völva, a seeress, and chants a valgaldr, a corpse-spell, until she rises and speaks, unwillingly, the words of the dead. He gives a false name. She tells him Balder will die, and near the end she recognises who he is.
In Hávamál, Odin lists the spells he knows. The twelfth: if he sees a hanged man swinging in a tree, he can carve and colour runes so that the man walks and talks with him. In Norse myth the dead are an archive, and Odin, who wants to know everything, keeps going back to it.
Erichtho: Rome Imagines the Worst
The necromancer as a figure of horror begins, in any fully developed form, with a poet. In book 6 of Lucan’s unfinished epic on the civil war, the Pharsalia, written under Nero, Sextus Pompey wants to know how the coming battle at Pharsalus will end. He goes to the witches of Thessaly, and to the worst of them, Erichtho, who lives among tombs.
She chooses a soldier’s corpse fresh enough that its lungs are undamaged, because it will need them to speak. She drags it back, fills its chest with hot blood and a catalogue of poisons, and calls a soul back into it. The soul does not want to return, and she has to threaten the powers below before it will. The corpse stands, prophesies ruin for Pompey’s house, and describes the dead of Rome already fighting their own civil war below. Then it asks to die again, and Erichtho has to build a pyre and burn it to let it go.
Set that beside Homer. Odysseus pours blood into a pit and waits for the dead to come to him. Erichtho puts the blood inside a body and forces the dead into it. Lucan knew his Virgil, and the scene is widely read as a dark reply to the Sibyl leading Aeneas through the underworld. It is not a report of practice. It is a poet’s image of what civil war does to a society, and it gave later literature its template for the necromancer who compels. The zombie and the lich are distant descendants of Erichtho, not of Odysseus.
From Necromancy to Nigromancy
In medieval Latin the word changed shape. Necromantia was respelled nigromantia, pulled toward niger, black, and the “black art” was born of a misreading. The meaning moved with the spelling. Isidore of Seville, in the seventh century, had already said that the dead who seem to come up at the smell of blood are really demons. If the thing answering is always a demon, then necromancy is simply demon-summoning, and by the later Middle Ages that is what the word meant.
The best evidence is a real manual. Richard Kieckhefer’s Forbidden Rites edits a fifteenth-century handbook in the Bavarian State Library in Munich, Clm 849. It contains conjurations, a catalogue of spirits, and a long ceremony for consecrating a book of magic. What the operations are for is revealing: illusions (a banquet, a castle, a horse with a red bridle that comes down out of the sky), manipulating other people’s minds and affections, and divination. The dead barely appear. In Magic in the Middle Ages Kieckhefer places this kind of magic in what he calls a “clerical underworld”: it required Latin and liturgy, and its practitioners were largely men with some clerical education. The medieval necromancer was a literate man with a book, much closer to the grimoire magician discussed in The Wise and the Wild than to the woman at Endor.
Who Still Asks
Consulting the dead is not only a historical practice.
On Osorezan, “Fear Mountain”, on the Shimokita peninsula in Aomori, Japan, the itako have practised kuchiyose: the dead speak through them, in the first person, to the relatives who have come to ask. Itako were traditionally blind or partially sighted women who trained for years under a senior itako and received beads and a sutra case when they qualified. The main gathering is the Itako Taisai, held at the temple on the mountain from 20 July. Carmen Blacker’s The Catalpa Bow (1975) is the classic study. Very few practise in the old way now, and at least one recent report counts only a handful.
The escort of the dead is a different office, and it is better described people by people than as a job every “Siberian shaman” did. Among the Nanai of the Amur basin, on the eastern edge of the Siberian world, the great memorial rite called kasa ended with the specialist conducting the dead person’s soul on the dangerous road to buni, the clan’s land of the dead, as Ivan Lopatin recorded in 1960. The Nanai language is Tungusic, a relative of the Evenki language that gave English the word “shaman”, which is a reason to use the word precisely, as Sorcerers, Shamans, and the Blurred Boundaries of Magic argues.
The same article covers the Mapuche machi. An earlier version of this essay called machi guides of the dead, without a source, and the ethnography puts other things first. Their work is healing and officiating, above all at the ngillatun. Their relationship with the dead is more intimate than escort. Ana Mariella Bacigalupo’s Thunder Shaman tells the life of Francisca Kolipi, who in 1960 was struck by lightning and possessed by the spirit of Rosa Kurin, a dead thunder machi, and whose own spirit her community expected to be reborn in a future machi. In Mapuche belief the honoured dead can also become pillán, the ancestral powers of thunder and volcano. The dead, here, are not visitors. They are predecessors.
What the Dead Are For
Put the evidence side by side and one pattern is plain. The dead are asked, far more often than they are commanded. Enkidu is questioned about the afterlife, Tiresias about the way home, Samuel about a battle, Melissa about a lost deposit, the völva about a dream, and the dead of Osorezan about whether they are at peace. What they know is what the living cannot find out any other way.
The direction is also consistent. The dead come up: through a hole, to a pit, out of the earth at Endor, from a grave at Hel’s door. Going down to them in person, as Orpheus and Inanna did, is a different story with a different cost.
And the price is always paid in the currency of the living: blood, food, clothes burned so a ghost can wear them, a calf fed to a doomed king. The necromancer who commands the dead is a late arrival: Lucan’s poem, the medieval demon-conjurer, the lich of 1975. The older figure, at the edge of the pit, wanted the thing that is hardest to get from anyone. An honest answer.
Further Reading
- Daniel Ogden, Greek and Roman Necromancy (Princeton University Press, 2001). The standard survey: the oracles of the dead, the techniques, Homer to late antiquity, and the case against the Ephyra identification.
- Daniel Ogden, Magic, Witchcraft and Ghosts in the Greek and Roman Worlds: A Sourcebook (Oxford University Press, 2002). The primary texts, including Homer’s pit, Herodotus on Melissa and Lucan’s Erichtho, in translation.
- Sarah Iles Johnston, Restless Dead: Encounters between the Living and the Dead in Ancient Greece (University of California Press, 1999). Why the Greek dead needed managing, and who managed them.
- Irving Finkel, The First Ghosts: Most Ancient of Legacies (2021). Mesopotamian ghosts and the necromancy tablets, by the curator who published them.
- JoAnn Scurlock, Magico-Medical Means of Treating Ghost-Induced Illnesses in Ancient Mesopotamia (Brill, 2006). The 352 prescriptions for getting rid of ghosts, which is most of the evidence.
- Andrew George, The Epic of Gilgamesh (Penguin, 1999). Includes Tablet XII and the Sumerian poem it translates.
- Esther J. Hamori, Women’s Divination in Biblical Literature: Prophecy, Necromancy, and Other Arts of Knowledge (Yale University Press, 2015). The woman at Endor among Israel’s other female diviners.
- Rowan A. Greer and Margaret M. Mitchell, The “Belly-Myther” of Endor: Interpretations of 1 Kingdoms 28 in the Early Church (Society of Biblical Literature, 2007). Origen, Eustathius and the rest, in translation.
- Fritz Graf and Sarah Iles Johnston, Ritual Texts for the Afterlife: Orpheus and the Bacchic Gold Tablets (Routledge, 2007). The tablets that gave the dead directions.
- Richard Kieckhefer, Forbidden Rites: A Necromancer’s Manual of the Fifteenth Century (1997). The Munich handbook, edited and translated.
- Richard Kieckhefer, Magic in the Middle Ages (Cambridge University Press, 1989). The clerical underworld and the shift from necromancy to nigromancy.
- Carmen Blacker, The Catalpa Bow: A Study of Shamanistic Practices in Japan (1975). The itako and Japanese mediumship.
- Ana Mariella Bacigalupo, Thunder Shaman: Making History with Mapuche Spirits in Chile and Patagonia (University of Texas Press, 2016). Francisca Kolipi and the dead machi who possessed her.
Explore More on Gods and Monsters
Mesopotamia: Gilgamesh · Enkidu · Nergal · Enki · Shamash · Inanna · Ereshkigal · Gidim · Edimmu · Mesopotamian Mythology · Sumerian Mythology
Greece and Rome: Odysseus · Circe · Aeaea · Tiresias · Shade · Achilles · Orpheus · Hades · Persephone · Aristaeus · Apollo · Mnemosyne · Aeneas · Greek Mythology · Roman Mythology
The Norse dead: Odin · Balder · Völva · Hel · Norse Mythology
Israel and its neighbours: Jewish Mythology · Hittite/Hurrian Mythology
The dead who still speak: Machi · Ngillatun · Pillán · Mapuche Mythology · Siberian and Arctic Peoples’ Mythologies · Japanese Mythology · Psychopomp
The necromancer’s descendants: Lich · Zombie · Demons · Medieval Mythology