Excalibur, a mythological object in English mythology

Excalibur

Also Known As: Welsh Caledfwlch; Latin Caliburnus; Caliburn; Old French Escalibor
Region/Culture: Northern Europe
Mythos: English Mythology, Welsh Mythology, Medieval Mythology
Primary Type/Nature: Mythological Objects
Mythical Attributes: Excalibur cuts through whatever it strikes and blazes with light when drawn, while its scabbard keeps the wearer from losing blood.
Role in Mythos: It is the sword of King Arthur, the sign of his kingship from his first wars to the day it is thrown back into the water.
Relation to Humans: The sword is lent to one king for one lifetime and must be given back when he falls. Lesser hands that hold it, by theft or by order, find it either fails them or is very hard to let go.

The knight stood at the edge of the water with the sword in both hands and could not do it. The pommel and the grip were thick with precious stones, the king who owned it was bleeding to death a short walk away, and throwing such a thing into a lake seemed to him plain waste. He hid it under a tree and went back and lied.

That hesitation, in the English telling the knight is Bedivere, comes at the very end of a long story. The sword it concerns had been a legend for at least four centuries before Sir Thomas Malory finished writing the scene in about 1470, and it had changed its name, its origin and half its nature along the way.

It starts in Wales as Caledfwlch, a name built from words meaning hard and breach or cleft. In *Culhwch and Olwen*, a prose tale usually dated to around 1100, Arthur lists it among the handful of possessions he will not give away to anyone, alongside his ship, his spear, his shield, his knife and his wife. It then does its work in someone else’s hand. A warrior named Llenlleawg the Irishman snatches it up, swings it, and kills the Irish steward Diwrnach and his whole company so that Arthur’s men can carry off a prized cauldron. No lake, no stone, no enchantress. A very good sword, used hard.

Geoffrey of Monmouth turned the name into Latin as Caliburnus in his *History of the Kings of Britain*, written in the 1130s, and added the first note of otherworldliness by saying it was forged on the isle of Avalon. In his account of the battle at Bath, Arthur draws it, calls on the Virgin, and cuts down four hundred and seventy Saxons by himself. French poets and romancers softened the word to Calibourne and then Escalibor, and English finally settled on Excalibur. Malory offered his own explanation that the name means cut steel, which is charming and wrong.

The two famous origin stories arrived later, and they were not at first about the same weapon. Around 1200 the French poet Robert de Boron told how a sword appeared in a churchyard at Christmas, fixed through an anvil set on a block of stone, and how only the boy Arthur could draw it out. That scene made him king. A generation afterwards the romance known as the Post-Vulgate *Merlin* supplied a second story. Arthur’s sword breaks in a fight with King Pellinore, and Merlin leads him to a lake. Out in the middle an arm clothed in white silk rises from the still surface holding a sword in its scabbard. Arthur and Merlin row out in a small boat, the king takes hold of it, and the arm slides back under. The Lady of the Lake asks only for a gift to be named later.

Malory kept both scenes, called both swords Excalibur at different moments, and never quite tidied up the contradiction. Readers have been arguing about it ever since. The plain reading of his book is that the stone sword proved the king and the lake sword armed him.

Most of the time it does what a royal sword does. It hangs at Arthur’s side through councils and feasts, heavy and quiet, and comes out when the fighting starts. In Malory’s account of the battle against the eleven rebel kings, Arthur draws it and it flares in his enemies’ eyes with the light of thirty torches. The Welsh *Dream of Rhonabwy* describes Arthur’s sword, without giving a name, as bearing two golden serpents, and says that when the blade left its sheath flame seemed to pour from their mouths so that it was hard to look at.

The sword cuts and dazzles. The scabbard is the better half. On the ride back from the lake Merlin asks Arthur which he prefers, and Arthur, being young and a soldier, says the sword. Merlin tells him the scabbard is worth ten of it, because whoever wears it will lose no blood however badly he is wounded. Arthur’s half-sister Morgan le Fay understands this better than he does. She steals the sword and gives it to her lover Accolon, leaving a brittle copy in its place, and Arthur nearly dies fighting against his own blade before he wins it back. Then she takes the scabbard and flings it into deep water, where it sinks out of the story. From that day the king can bleed like any other man.

That is the whole weakness of Excalibur. It is only ever on loan. It can be copied, stolen, and turned on its owner, its protection depends on a piece of leather and wood that a clever thief can carry off under her cloak, and it must go back where it came from.

So the story returns to the cold shore after the last battle, with Arthur wounded past saving and ordering the sword thrown in. Twice the knight hides it and reports that he saw nothing but wind and waves, and twice the dying king knows he is lying. The third time he throws it as far as he can. A hand comes up out of the water, catches the sword by the hilt, shakes it three times, and draws it under. In the older French version of the scene the knight is Girflet. Either way the lake keeps it.

The Irish hero Fergus mac Róich carried a sword called Caladbolg whose name is plainly cousin to Caledfwlch, and nobody has settled which story borrowed from which. As for the thing itself, the chronicler Roger of Howden records that in 1191 King Richard I of England presented Tancred of Sicily with a sword said to be Arthur’s own. What became of that one is not recorded.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Excalibur?

Excalibur is the sword of King Arthur in Welsh, French and English legend. It first appears in Welsh as Caledfwlch and in Geoffrey of Monmouth’s Latin history as Caliburnus, forged on the isle of Avalon. It cuts through anything, shines with blinding light when drawn, and comes with a scabbard that stops its wearer from losing blood.

Is Excalibur the sword in the stone?

In the earliest versions the sword in the stone and Excalibur are separate stories. Robert de Boron, around 1200, told of the sword Arthur drew from an anvil on a stone to prove he was king, and a later French romance told of a second sword given to Arthur from a lake after his first one broke. Sir Thomas Malory kept both stories and used the name Excalibur for both swords.

Who gave Excalibur to King Arthur?

In the lake version of the story, the Lady of the Lake gave Excalibur to King Arthur. Merlin led Arthur to a lake where an arm clothed in white silk held the sword above the water, and Arthur rowed out and took it. The Lady of the Lake asked for a gift in return, to be named later.

Why was Excalibur’s scabbard more valuable than the sword?

Excalibur’s scabbard kept whoever wore it from losing blood, no matter how badly he was wounded. Merlin told Arthur the scabbard was worth ten of the sword. Morgan le Fay later stole the scabbard and threw it into deep water, and after that Arthur could be wounded like any other man.

What happened to Excalibur when Arthur died?

Excalibur was thrown back into the water after Arthur’s last battle. The wounded king ordered a knight, Bedivere in the English version and Girflet in the older French one, to throw it in, and the knight hid it twice before obeying. A hand rose from the water, caught the sword, shook it three times and pulled it under.

Related Entries

Arthur, Merlin, Morgan le Fay, Avalon, Fisher King, Green Knight, Questing Beast, Twrch Trwyth, Dyrnwyn, Sigurd, Kusanagi-no-Tsurugi (Ame-no-Murakumo-no-Tsurugi)